• If you are new to GiantScaleNews.com, please register, introduce yourself, and make yourself at home.

    We're 1st in Giant Scale RC because we've got the best membership on the internet! Take a look around and don't forget to register to get all of the benefits of GSN membership!

    Welcome!

Pop goes the prop!

Something real weird to share with you all...
DISCLAIMER: This is in no way a bashing of any brands or trying to cause any hysteria or any other type of drama. Only want to share something that happened today with you all. See what you all think...


I purchased this prop brand new. 30 x 13 EVO prop. I used it on an IMAC airplane with a 170 cc engine and stock muffs. Worked well.

I upgraded airplanes, and had this laying around. I flew it for maybe 20 flights or so. Never a nose over or a prop strike, never involved in a crash.

OK, prop was just collecting dust, my buddy needed a prop, so I sold it to him for 80 Dollars. He competed in 3 competitions with it,. He has put over 40 flights with this prop.

we flew on Wednesday and again today.

He brings his plane and sets it up, he cranks it up, takes off, turns to head north, climbing at about 30 degrees or so, temps are about 101 F, and crosswind from west. All of a sudden, we heard a "POP", kind of like a back fire, or something, he immediately cut the power and lands it.

Brings it back in, and we start to inspect it, I immediately noticed this....

IMG_8651.JPG
IMG_8652.JPG
IMG_8653.JPG
IMG_8654.JPG




SO , it looks like it delaminated on one side. Good thing my buddy immediately brought the power down. I could imagine, had he throttled up again, that one side would have flown off, maybe hitting the wings or the stabs/fin, then it having only one prop on, would have created incredible out of balance, that would have made the nose shake so much, could have damaged the motor-box!

But of course none of this happened!!
We were very lucky.

Ok, someone suggested: Maybe the prop hit something during transport or it was tapped.

Someone else said, maybe a rock on the ground (do not believe so because if you inspect the prop blades, not a single chip)

I think, maybe he hit a Louisiana bug (up ion the air) that was maybe bigger than most?
 

stangflyer

I like 'em "BIG"!
Kind of spooky there Ortho.... But I'm glad your buddy got it home safe and sound. That is pretty odd for sure.
 

jon595

50cc
Had that happen before about 5 years ago. In talking with the importer (DA) they made it right by replacing it. Worth a shot anyway.
 
I do not blame DA or anyone else. I am not looking for any compensation in any way. I merely wanted to share this with you all, maybe if it happens to someone else, they can see it is not an isolated event. It is purely an FYI type of thing. I did however ask, and I had 90 days to claim a problem from the time of purchase, which is fair enough to me. I can see, if there was a problem, it would have arisen early on. Maybe? Anyways, I obtained it over 1 year ago, and it spent most of its time collecting dust. Again, I posted this so that it is on record, if anyone else has the same thing happen, then it will be something interesting to share with the manufacturer.
 

dhal22

GSN Sponsor Tier 1
I had a 28" prop delam like that after a slight prop strike. Same brand. Taxied off the asphalt runway and nosed over a bit as the wheels transitioned to grass. Wasn't much but the results were similar.
 

Pistolera

HEY!..GET OUTTA MY TREE!
It happens. I had one Biela 28x12x3 split (DA150/RE3 combo), and another one crack at the web between the blades. Biela replaced them both :fist_pump:
DSC02768.jpg
DSC02769.jpg
 

acerc

640cc Uber Pimp
Not uncommon at all at my field either, actually happens at least once a weekend. This is the very reason I stay with wood.
 
But wood is so much louder, and wood compresses at the hub, so you have to make sure to tighten them often. (or be sure they are still tight)
 
Top